Pros: Weight, Overall Quality, Blade Material, Finish, Blade Sharpness
Cons: Handle Material, Sheath/Scabbard
Reprise
I had a Vanguard in the 80's. It was one of my favorite knives. Loved the way it fit my hand. It had the expected Buck ability to take and hold a sharp edge. With one exception which I'll go into in a moment, it did everything I asked of it, the way a good knife should. But, as too often happens, it got away from me at some point and I never replaced it. Until now. This new Vanguard is exactly the same as the old one, in every respect but one. Maybe two. The new nylon/plastic insert sheath, while functional, is a poor substitute for the nice leather sheath these knives wore back in the day. It's hard to remember, but I believe the old blade might have had a bit nicer polish on it, but maybe not. As I said, there was one thing the old Vanguard simply did not do, and that speaks to what I was saying about today's Vanguards being identical to the old ones. These knives have a powerful chemical odor from the rubber handle material. It is a disappointment that Buck has never done anything about it. I never was able to fully de-scent the handle on my old knife, so it always stayed home on bowhunting expeditions. Bowhunters would be better served with the wood handled version, in my opinion. For all other hunts where scent isn't that big of a problem, the rubber handle makes for a very comfortable, non-slip grip. So, I knock off a half point for the sheath and another half point for Buck never solving the odor issue. Not quite excellent. Still, it's nice to have an old favorite back in the fold.