Pros: Blade Sharpness, Ease of Opening, Handle Material, Lock Type, Overall Quality, Pocket Clip, Weight
Cons: Blade Material, Handle Feel, Lock Ease of Use
An Acceptable imitation of the OG Skyline
First off - I'm super excited to see the Skyline brought back by this Knife Center collaboration with Kershaw - big kudos the the folks in both companies for making this happen. As a big Kershaw fan, I've collected my fair share of their knives - both USA made and some made in their Chinese factories. The USA made knives are generally a notch above their foreign-made knives, but there are some surprise in either category. I was hoping the Mini Skyline would live up to the standards set by its predecessor, and it largely has. The good: - The slightly smaller size is fine for me, I hardly notice the difference - The overall build and style stay true to the original Skyline - I don't miss the lack of thumbstud - Blade had good grind and edge - Flicks open easier than most original Skylines do Not so good: - Not made in the USA (if this matters to you). I'm largely ambivalent about this point, but some Kershaws from Chinese factories lack the consistency you see from their US QA lines - D2 steel is *fine* but not exciting. At least they didn't cheap out with generic stainless - The frame lock is harder to disengage than the original Skyline. Takes some fun out of this being a good fidget knife. In fact 1 of the 3 Minis I bought had a frame lock that went past the 1/2 way make of the blade and it catches a big, making it a slight struggle to close - The box: Here's my tiny nitpick. I bought 3 NEW Minis and 1 had a box that look like the flap edges were cut by a toddler using scissors. Bleh - No tip-down carry option. You get left or right options on the clip with this one, but no tip-down option like the OG Skyline had - Grippy pivot - despite having KV bearings for fast deployment, if you hold the framelock out of the way, the bearings on all 3 Minis I bought was a little grindy. I went to loosen the pivot bolt and it's glued in hard with loctite. Kershaw says I can heat the bolt gently and unscrew it a tad to back off the pivot pressure, or send it in for service to their US HQ. I haven't tried either option yet, but I do know I would have stripped the Torx head trying to unscrew it cold. - G10 handle - nice thickness, but find the checkering a bit more aggressive than the OG Skylines (even my NIB collectibles). Overall - glad to own a few of these and will be using 1 as an EDC happily. My review may seem critical for people new to the Skyline series, but I wanted to share these findings for those of you considering adding it to your collection.