Pros: Weight, Overall Quality, Blade Material, Sheath/Scabbard, Materials, Finish
Cons: Blade Sharpness
Excellent sheath, excellent handle, good steel for wet conditions, but
I seem to be collecting neck knives in an undoubtedly futile quest to find the perfect EDC knife to open carry. The statutes in Florida, where I live, allow open carry of any blade except a ballistic knife. (Local laws vary.) The ARK has an excellent sheath that holds the knife very securely. You can draw the knife quickly and easily because your forefinger naturally presses a tab that releases the sheath lock. The handle is comfortable and provides a secure grip with the finger notch. But if you have big hands, you might prefer a bigger knife. The ARK has H1 steel. I'm happy with H1, although many people dislike H1 Steel because it does not hold an edge as well as most other non-junk steels. But where I live, it has rained every day except three out of the last six weeks, and H1 is practically rust proof. And when it is not raining, the heat index is often over 100F, so again my shirt will be wet. My EDC knife is a Spyderco Pacific Salt 2 with H1 steel--it's great (push-cuts paper), although I would love to get one with LC200N. I noticed that, out of the box, the ARK could not slice typing paper (a routine test of sharpness). H1 is easy to sharpen, so I was not terrible concerned. But ... My wife asked to borrow a knife to open an ebay package covered with tape. I handed her the ARK, which happened to be on my neck. After some struggle, she got the package open and remarked that the ARK was slightly sharper than her thumbnail. Then she tried to cut the cardboard seal on top of a jug of fertilizer. The ARK failed. Her thumbnail succeeded. I did some more sharpness testing. Out of dozens of knives that I have bought, the ARK was the second dullest out of the box. Spyderco is known for making high-quality sharpening instruments, yet they ship a knife that is about as sharp as a common butter knife. Spyderco should be embarrassed. I usually do not downrate a knife for being a bit dull out of the box, but this is an extreme case.